David H. Peiffer and the Development of Historical Research from Middle Eastern Studies to Cumberland County History
Photo Courtesy: Unsplash.com

David H. Peiffer and the Development of Historical Research from Middle Eastern Studies to Cumberland County History

Local history is often built from records that were not originally intended to become historical sources. Property deeds, family papers, newspaper accounts, church records, government documents, photographs and oral recollections can each preserve only part of a story. Bringing those pieces together can change how a community understands a building, family or public figure. In Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, this type of research has remained an active part of the work of the Cumberland County Historical Society (CCHS), whose journal has been published since 1984 and covers the county’s history and culture across the 19th, 20th and 21st centuries. The society also invites researchers to submit new studies or reassessments of subjects that have already been documented.

David H. Peiffer’s historical writing developed from an earlier academic interest in the Middle East. He graduated from Grove City College in 1981 with a bachelor’s degree in history and later studied at the University of Michigan, where he earned a master’s degree in Near Eastern and North African Studies in 1984. During 1982 and 1983, he was a University of Michigan Rackham Exchange Fellow at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. That background placed his early research within the study of Israel, regional politics and the history of the Near East. His later writing moved toward the history of central Pennsylvania, but the basic interest in records, place and political or social change remained present in both periods.

One of his earlier publications was Beyond the Green Line: Israel’s Strategic Calculus in Judea and Samaria, published in 2006. The work examined strategic questions connected with Israel and the territories beyond the Green Line. Peiffer’s research during this period also contributed to work associated with Rachel Bronson at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. His research was also connected with Israel in the Middle East: Documents and Readings on Society, Politics, and Foreign Relations, Pre-1948 to the Present, the documentary history edited by Itamar Rabinovich and Jehuda Reinharz. The second edition, published by Brandeis University Press in 2007 and 2008 editions, drew heavily on primary sources and covered Israeli domestic and foreign policy from the pre-state period through 2006.

The change in subject matter became clearer in Peiffer’s later publications. Rather than concentrating on national or international affairs, he began examining people and places in Cumberland County and nearby communities. His 2022 article, Out of the Frying Pan and Into the Fire: Trials and Tribulations of Cumberland County’s First Female Commissioner, appeared in volume 38 of Cumberland County History. The subject was Rosemarie Peiffer, who became Cumberland County’s first female commissioner in 1979. The article formed part of a broader effort to document an episode of local political history through the experiences of an individual officeholder.

That research later expanded into Moxie Rose: Curious Accounts of Trials and Tribulations From the Life of Cumberland County’s First Female Commissioner, published by the Cumberland County Historical Society in 2023. The book runs to 195 pages and examines Rosemarie Peiffer’s early life, public career, and time in county government. The work illustrates one method found repeatedly in Peiffer’s later writing: using the life of one person to examine a wider community and its institutions. Rather than treating local history only as a record of buildings and dates, his books also consider family relationships, political activity, religion, and the circumstances surrounding individual decisions.

Another example is Serving Up Salvation One Ladle at a Time: The Shopp Family at Cedar Run. The 72-page book was published by the Cumberland County Historical Society in 2023 after an earlier version of the research appeared in Cumberland County History, volume 39, in 2022. The study examined the Shopp family property in Hampden Township and its connection to the early United Brethren movement. Contemporary reporting later noted that Peiffer’s research examined the property’s religious history, the family’s land, and events extending into the Civil War and World War I. The farmhouse itself was demolished in November 2022 after years of deterioration and vandalism, making the documentary record one of the remaining ways to examine its history.

Property research became an even larger part of Bonding With the William Black Homestead: Tales of Passion and Obsession, published by the Cumberland County Historical Society in 2024. The book traces the William Black Homestead and related people, structures, and land in New Cumberland. His related journal articles include Mysteries of the William Black Homestead Resolved: The Once Unknown Now Known and Correcting the Mish Mash Surrounding the Location of the Miesch Mansion, both published in volume 41 of Cumberland County History in 2024. Earlier, in 2023, he published The Apple Pie Caper and the CVRR, examining an episode connected with the Cumberland Valley Railroad. Together, these works show a research approach centered on property history, local records, and reconstructing events from surviving evidence.

His more recent books have continued that approach. Arlea at Foxlea: The Story of the Forgotten Girl Scout Camp Near New Cumberland was published in 2025 and examined a lesser-known part of the area’s community history. Rectangles in New Cumberland: Anecdotes of Anely and Jacob Knopf Casting Their Bread Upon the Waters followed in 2026, focusing on the Knopf family and its place in New Cumberland’s past. In June 2026, Peiffer and Robert C. Landis published Rib of My Rib: The Rise of Women Leaders in New Cumberland. The book records the lives of five women who entered public service in New Cumberland during the 1970s and 1980s. Its subjects include D. Marie Phillips, Rosemarie Peiffer, Mary Landis, D.J. Landis and Judy Dillen.

The pattern across these publications is less about a single historical period than about recovering material that can otherwise remain outside larger histories. The subjects range from an Israeli strategic study in 2006 to county government, religious communities, railroad history, historic properties, and women’s public service in central Pennsylvania. The Cumberland County Historical Society provides an established publication setting for much of this work. Its journal requires citations and follows the Chicago Manual of Style, while its stated purpose includes maintaining historical accuracy and supporting researchers.

Peiffer’s historical work has also received institutional recognition. Grove City College lists his publications among the works of its alumni and notes that he received the Jack Kennedy Distinguished Alumni Award in 2020. The Cumberland County Historical Society named him the Milton E. Flower Historian of the Year in 2025. These recognitions sit alongside a research record that has expanded considerably since his university studies in the early 1980s. From Near Eastern history and Israel studies to local families, properties and public institutions, his published work has increasingly focused on preserving details of Cumberland County’s past. David H. Peiffer’s historical writing therefore forms a record of that shift in subject, method, and geographic focus.

This article features branded content from a third party. Opinions in this article do not reflect the opinions and beliefs of New York Weekly.