The Executive Hiring Mistakes That Can Derail PE Value Creation
Photo Courtesy: Unsplash.com

The Executive Hiring Mistakes That Can Derail PE Value Creation

By: Avetis Antaplyan, Founder and CEO of HIRECLOUT

The Leadership Layer Below the CEO

Private equity firms devote enormous time to underwriting a deal. They stress-test the financial model, study the market, and construct a value creation plan. Yet according to Avetis Antaplyan, founder and CEO of executive search firm HIRECLOUT, one of the biggest variables in whether that plan is executed often receives far less diligence: the people responsible for delivering it.

Most of the attention, Antaplyan notes, goes to the top of the house. In its January 2026 report, Closing the Leadership Gap in Private Equity, Heidrick & Struggles observed that sponsors are frequently involved in CEO, CFO and board appointments but often lack the bandwidth to focus on the broader C-suite. That, in his view, is where the gap opens. A value creation plan is rarely executed by the CEO alone. It is carried out by the leaders who rebuild reporting, modernize technology, reshape the commercial engine and translate strategy into weekly execution.

AlixPartners’ 11th Annual Private Equity Leadership Survey found that 65% of PE firms experience CEO turnover during the holding period, while only 9% said they rarely replace chief executives. As Antaplyan frames it, the financial model identifies the opportunity, but the leadership team creates the value.

Mistake #1: Hiring for Credentials Instead of the Mandate

An impressive executive is not necessarily the right executive for a PE-backed company, Antaplyan argues. Previous titles, prestigious employers and sponsor-backed experience are useful signals, but none of them answers the question that matters most: whether the person can execute this specific value creation plan.

He points to several common mismatches. A finance leader who excelled inside a stable $1 billion enterprise may struggle in a $150 million company undergoing rapid transformation. A technology executive who scaled one platform may be poorly suited to consolidating four. A commercial leader who thrives in steady-state account management may not be the person to rebuild a go-to-market motion in eighteen months.

When a search is worked backward from the value creation plan, Antaplyan says, the profile often changes. Organic growth calls for a builder. Operational efficiency calls for a transformer. A buy-and-build strategy calls for an integrator of companies, systems, teams and cultures. In his assessment, the mandate, not the resume, should define the hire.

Mistake #2: Waiting Until After Close to Assess the Team

Postponing leadership assessment until after the transaction closes is expensive, according to Antaplyan, because by then the clock is already running. He contends that the first 30 days are better spent implementing leadership decisions and aligning the organization than working out whether the inherited team can execute the plan.

AlixPartners found in its 10th Annual Private Equity Leadership Survey that 86% of portfolio-company CEO turnover was driven by the PE firm rather than initiated by the executive. Yet only 46% of PE firms said they discussed succession regularly. Antaplyan reads those figures as evidence that turnover is not something that simply happens to investors. It follows from the decisions investors make about whether the team can execute the plan, and he argues those decisions are better made before performance deteriorates.

As early as access reasonably allows, he recommends that sponsors ask:

  • Which leaders are critical to retain, and who can take on more?
  • Where are the capability and succession gaps?
  • Which roles will change as the plan advances?
  • Where would losing one person create material execution risk?
  • Which searches should launch immediately?

Not every answer will be available before close. Even so, Antaplyan maintains that Day One is more productive when it begins with a talent thesis rather than a blank sheet of paper.

Mistake #3: Allowing Uncertainty to Become a Retention Problem

Acquisitions create uncertainty, and uncertainty creates attrition. Employees want to know what the transaction means for their roles, compensation and future. When leadership fails to communicate clearly, Antaplyan observes, people fill in the blanks themselves, and the strongest performers usually have the most alternatives.

The risk, he notes, often sits one or two layers below the C-suite, among the people who hold customer relationships, institutional knowledge and operational continuity. Leaders cannot promise certainty where none exists, but they can clarify what is known, what is changing, when decisions will be made and how success will be measured. Silence, in Antaplyan’s words, is not a retention strategy.

Mistake #4: Assuming the Existing Team Can Absorb the Transformation

Running a company and transforming one are different jobs, Antaplyan says. A functional leader may already be responsible for hitting targets, managing customers, leading a team and controlling costs. Add systems integration, organizational redesign, synergy capture and change management to that workload, and something eventually gives.

The answer, in his view, is not always permanent headcount. Interim leaders, integration specialists and experienced operators can add capacity during a defined window. Some capabilities should be built internally, some hired permanently and others engaged for six or twelve months. Treating every gap as a permanent hire, he cautions, can be as inefficient as leaving it unfilled.

Mistake #5: Hiring for Today’s Scale Instead of Tomorrow’s

Antaplyan draws a distinction between two tests. Mandate fit asks whether an executive can accomplish the work. Stage fit asks whether that executive can keep succeeding as the business becomes materially different.

The company a sponsor acquires is rarely the company it intends to sell. The controller who was excellent at $80 million may not be the CFO the business needs at $250 million with three acquisitions integrated. The engineering leader who built the original product may not be the one to run a platform organization.

An executive can be excellent in the current job and still not be right for the next stage. Antaplyan advises sponsors to evaluate whether the executive has operated at the target scale, navigated the complexity the plan will introduce, built a capable organization beneath them and delivered on today’s goals while preparing for tomorrow. These gaps may not surface immediately, he warns, and by the time they do, a meaningful portion of the hold period may be gone.

A Better Talent Playbook

Pre-Close: Develop the Talent Thesis

Antaplyan’s playbook begins before the deal closes. Sponsors should assess the leadership team as far as access permits, including the layer below the C-suite, and translate the investment thesis into the capabilities required to execute it. That work should identify critical leaders, retention risks, succession concerns and likely gaps.

Days 1 to 30: Create Clarity

In the first month, he recommends that sponsors confirm critical roles and decision rights, align incentives where appropriate, establish the operating cadence and translate the thesis into measurable priorities.

Days 31 to 90: Build the Team for Execution

The next phase is about addressing gaps decisively: launching critical searches and adding interim or specialized resources where permanent hiring is not warranted. For critical hires, Antaplyan advises beginning with the mandate rather than a candidate list. A search that starts with the job description, he says, will optimize for credentials instead of outcomes.

The Bottom Line

Private equity is a race against time, Antaplyan says. Every quarter spent carrying the wrong leader, leaving a critical seat vacant or asking an overstretched team to perform work it was not built for carries a cost. Earlier AlixPartners research found that 83% of PE executives said unplanned CEO turnover lengthens holding periods, while nearly half said it reduces returns.

He concludes that talent strategy cannot sit downstream from the value creation plan. It has to be part of it. The question for sponsors, as he puts it, is whether the company has the right people, with the right capabilities, at the right stage and deep enough into the organization to execute the plan the deal was built around.

About Avetis Antaplyan

Avetis Antaplyan is the Founder and CEO of HIRECLOUT, a global technology and go-to-market executive search and talent solutions firm.

Sources

AlixPartners, 11th Annual Private Equity Leadership Survey, March 25, 2026.

AlixPartners, 10th Annual Private Equity Leadership Survey, March 25, 2025.

Heidrick & Struggles, Closing the Leadership Gap in Private Equity, January 27, 2026.

This article features branded content from a third party. Opinions in this article do not reflect the opinions and beliefs of New York Weekly.