A denial letter from a car manufacturer tends to read like a final answer. It is polite and brief, and it leaves the owner with the same defective car and the same monthly payment. Many owners stop there. They assume the company has looked at the facts and made a decision the law supports.
George Mkrtchyan, Esq., Managing Attorney of Court House Lawyers in Glendale, California, sees that letter differently. In his view, a manufacturer’s denial of an unrepresented owner’s lemon law claim is a position, not a ruling.
The same repair history, laid out the way the statute reads it, can lead to a different result. One Mercedes-Benz lemon law case shows why.
A Mercedes-Benz Lemon Law Claim, Denied Once
The vehicle was a leased Mercedes-Benz hybrid with recurring engine and battery problems. The owner took it in for repairs 3 times. Across those visits, it spent more than 30 days out of service. When the owner pursued a lemon law claim alone, Mercedes denied it.
That record tracked the measures the statute uses. Under California Civil Code § 1793.22, a vehicle can be presumed a lemon after 30 or more cumulative days out of service for repairs within 18 months or 18,000 miles of delivery.
Repeated repair attempts for the same defect are another path. The presumption is not the only way to qualify. It does show how the statute expects a claim to be measured: by repair attempts and days out of service, documented visit by visit.
What Changed When the Lemon Law Claim Was Presented Again
The facts did not change. The car, the repair orders, and the days in the shop were the same. What changed was the form of the request. The firm submitted a formal repurchase demand and contract rescission built on the documented repair history. A rescission request asks, in effect, to unwind the contract. For a lease, that means returning the vehicle and recovering what was paid under it, less any mileage offset. The demand organized the repair history by concern and by total days out of service, which is how Mkrtchyan generally structures these requests.
“The claim was denied when the consumer presented it himself,” Mkrtchyan says. “Once it was presented through the proper channels, with legal language holding the manufacturer accountable and the repair history documented the way the statute contemplates, the answer was different. The facts had not changed. How they were presented did.”
The outcome is listed on the Mercedes-Benz lemon law page of Court House Lawyers. Mercedes agreed to a full repurchase and waived the mileage offset entirely, which added $5,250 to what the client received. The firm’s fee did not increase, because in California lemon law cases the manufacturer pays the attorney’s fees separately under § 1794.

Why the Mileage Offset Waiver in a Buyback Is Rare
The offset waiver is the unusual part of the result. In a California buyback, the mileage offset reduces the refund for the miles the owner drove before the first repair visit for the defect. It is calculated as the purchase price multiplied by the miles at that first visit, divided by 120,000. On most buybacks, that deduction simply comes off the total.
Mercedes occasionally waives the offset. It is rare, and no owner should count on it. The waiver in this case shows that a repurchase can be negotiated rather than simply calculated. It does not set an expectation for any other owner.
What Mercedes-Benz Owners Can Check Before a Lemon Law Claim
Owners can do useful work before anyone files a demand. The first step is the record itself. Each repair order should describe the specific symptom the driver experienced, the date the car came in, and the date it was returned. Those dates add up to days out of service. Owners who keep their own copy of every repair order are not relying on the dealer to produce the file later, and that file is what any demand would be built on.
The second step is checking public safety data. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration lets owners run a recall lookup by VIN or license plate, and the same site accepts reports of safety problems that could be defects. Owners can also look up Technical Service Bulletins, the manufacturer’s repair guidance to dealers, for a known issue that matches their symptoms.
A recall result can be misread in both directions. A recall notice on its own does not make a car a lemon, and a car with no recall can still qualify. The claim itself generally rests on what the repair orders show.
“An owner who takes on a manufacturer alone can wait longer for an answer and get the short end of the stick.” Mkrtchyan states. “That isn’t a reason to stop pursuing a claim. It is a reason not to let the denial letter be the only document anyone reads.”
Mkrtchyan, who earned his JD with honors from Abraham Lincoln University School of Law, treats a denial as the beginning of a review rather than the end of one. For an owner holding a denial, that kind of reading is often the most useful thing to get, and because fees are paid by the manufacturer when the consumer prevails, getting it can cost the owner nothing out of the buyback.
The denial letter in this case said no. The repair orders said something else. In the end, the repair orders carried more weight.
Disclaimer: This article is intended for general informational purposes only and should not be considered legal advice. The information provided may not apply to every situation, and individual circumstances may vary. Past results do not guarantee or predict future outcomes. Readers are encouraged to consult a qualified legal professional for advice specific to their circumstances.










