By: Jeremy Murphy
Long before he was handling complex civil litigation and sensitive family law matters at Aidala, Bertuna & Kamins, Michael DiBenedetto learned some of life’s most important lessons in one of New York City’s most iconic family businesses.
Raised on Staten Island, DiBenedetto grew up surrounded by the value of hard work. His family owns L&B Spumoni Gardens, the legendary Brooklyn restaurant that has become a destination for generations of New Yorkers. Working in and around the family business taught him that success comes from treating people well and understanding that every customer deserves respect.
Those lessons remain central to his legal practice today. “My father is Italian, and my mother is Austrian,” he says. “Both instilled in me the importance of family, perseverance, and compassion.” Those values eventually led him to a career where helping people through some of the most difficult moments of their lives became his daily work.
Building a Diverse Practice
Today, DiBenedetto focuses primarily on civil litigation at the firm, while also maintaining an active practice in divorce, family law, and estate matters. Although civil litigation occupies most of his time, he enjoys the diversity the field offers.
“Civil litigation encompasses a lot of different areas,” he says. “Whether it’s torts, contracts, real estate, or fighting over land, there are so many different types of cases.”
Among his favorite matters are business disputes, where complicated facts and high financial stakes require careful legal strategy. He recalls representing an investor who had contributed $1 million to a restaurant venture and was being denied the ownership interest he had been promised.
His interest in family law, however, goes back even further. While attending law school in Newark, he clerked for a family court judge and worked at a family law firm. Those experiences reinforced his desire to help families navigate challenging situations with steady legal guidance.
A Competitor’s Mindset
Long before the courtroom, DiBenedetto developed his career-defining discipline on athletic fields. A standout baseball player through college, he credits the sport with teaching him preparation and teamwork. He also excelled as a distance runner, a skill that requires relentless commitment and mental toughness.
Those same qualities shape his legal practice. Whether preparing for trial, negotiating a settlement, or advocating for clients, he believes persistence makes the difference.
From an early age, he knew he wanted to become an attorney to help people during moments when they were least equipped to help themselves. “I’ve always been drawn to helping people,” he says. “I wanted to be someone who could step in and be their advocate.”
Growing Alongside the Firm
DiBenedetto joined the firm in August 2019, when it was significantly smaller than it is today. “When I started, there were probably eight to ten attorneys,” he says. “Now we’re around 15 to 20.” He has watched both the firm and its civil litigation practice expand while maintaining the collaborative atmosphere that attracted him to it.
“The firm is a great place to work,” he says. “Everyone works hard, but everyone also enjoys working together.”
Although his practice differs from that of many of the firm’s criminal defense attorneys, he says collaboration remains one of its greatest strengths. He has particularly benefited from working alongside retired appellate judge John M. Leventhal, who has become an important mentor of his. “He’s helped me immensely,” DiBenedetto says.
Never Backing Away from a Challenge
That collaborative spirit became especially evident during the firm’s representation of legendary music executive L.A. Reid in a high-profile federal civil case. The legal team inherited the matter just before trial and immediately faced an avalanche of motions, depositions, and last-minute filings.
“There were nights we left the office at two in the morning,” DiBenedetto recalls. “I went home for about three hours and came back at seven.” For him, those demanding schedules reflect the firm’s willingness to embrace difficult cases without hesitation. “When we have something that has to get done, everyone works together,” he says.
The Cases That Matter Most
Despite handling sophisticated commercial litigation, some of DiBenedetto’s most meaningful victories have come in family court.
One case involved a father who had been separated from his young children for years amid an intensely contested custody dispute. After lengthy litigation, DiBenedetto secured visitation rights, allowing the father to reunite with his children.
Later, the client sent him a photograph of that first visit. “It was the first time he’d seen his kids in years,” DiBenedetto says. “He sent me a picture thanking me.” Those moments, he says, remind him why he chose this profession.
For DiBenedetto, the practice of law has never simply been about winning cases. It has always been about standing beside people during life’s most difficult moments and helping them find a path forward.
Disclaimer: The content in this article is provided for general knowledge. It does not constitute legal advice, and readers should seek advice from qualified legal professionals regarding particular cases or situations.











