By: James Davids
Set to be released in May 2025, in conjunction with Peace Officers Memorial Day, A Second Shot by Michael F. Weisberg is more than just a true crime narrative—it is a testament to perseverance, justice, and redemption. The book chronicles the decades-long investigation into the 1971 murder of Montgomery County Deputy Sheriff James Tappen Hall, a case that haunted both law enforcement and Hall’s family for half a century.
A Case That Refused to Fade
In October 1971, Deputy Sheriff J.T. Hall was found face-down in a parking lot at the Manor Country Club in Rockville, Maryland, suffering from a gunshot wound. Three days later, he succumbed to his injuries, leaving behind a grieving family and a mystery that would remain unsolved for fifty years.
Weisberg meticulously reconstructs the investigation, capturing the frustration of dead-end leads and the unwavering commitment of detectives who refused to let the case go cold. Then, after decades of uncertainty, law enforcement made a breakthrough: a suspect, Larry David Smith, was tracked down living under an alias in upstate New York. In a dramatic interrogation, Smith confessed to the crime, revealing a previously undisclosed detail that confirmed his guilt—Hall had been shot twice.
More Than Just a Crime Story
Beyond the procedural aspects of solving the case, A Second Shot delves into the emotional and psychological toll the crime had on Hall’s loved ones and the law enforcement officers determined to bring his killer to justice. Weisberg’s in-depth interviews and firsthand accounts bring the human element to the forefront, transforming the book from a simple true crime read into a profound exploration of grief, hope, and resilience.
A Personal Connection to the Theme of Redemption
What makes this book particularly compelling is Weisberg’s personal journey. While writing A Second Shot, he survived a near-fatal car accident and a serious illness. These experiences reinforced the book’s core theme—second chances. His survival and subsequent determination to complete the book mirror the tenacity of those who never stopped seeking justice for Hall.
A Unique Blend of Science and Storytelling
Weisberg’s background as a doctor adds an additional layer of credibility and depth. His background in forensic science enables him to examine investigative techniques thoughtfully, while his narrative style keeps the story engaging and approachable. The book finds a balance between factual detail and engaging storytelling, appealing to both true crime readers and a broader audience.
An Insightful Read for Justice Advocates
A Second Shot stands out in the true crime genre. It offers the intrigue of an unsolved mystery, the emotional impact of a family’s long wait for justice, and the inspiration of persistence paying off. Weisberg’s background as both a scientist and a storyteller adds depth to the book, offering a thoughtful reflection on justice and second chances, beyond just a crime retelling.
Weisberg provides a detailed and personal look at a case that unfolded over time. A Second Shot explores the challenges of solving a murder, along with themes of perseverance and justice. The book offers insight for those interested in true crime or stories of resilience.
A SECOND SHOT: The Pursuit of Justice in Maryland’s Oldest Cold Case Murder
By Michael F. Weisberg, M.D.
Intelligentsia Books / May 5, 2025
ISBN: 979-8-9927859-0-6, paperback, $14.99
ISBN: 979-8-9927859-1-3, eBook, $5.99
Disclaimer: The information in this article is intended for general informational purposes. The details provided are based on available sources and may not be complete or accurate.
Published by Joseph T.
