How High-Growth Businesses Diversify Their Advertising Mix Beyond Search
Photo: Unsplash.com

How High-Growth Businesses Diversify Their Advertising Mix Beyond Search

Search advertising works until it doesn’t. For most businesses, there’s a point where every relevant keyword is covered, bids are as competitive as they can justify, and the growth curve starts flattening. Customer acquisition costs creep up, returns thin out, and the team starts wondering what comes next. That ceiling is real, and the companies that break through it don’t do so by bidding harder on the same keywords.

Why Search Can’t Scale Indefinitely

Searching the web meets existing demand. A customer types in a keyword, your advertisement is displayed, and the user clicks. This system is effective as the customer is already looking for something. However, this is also the main limitation of this system; you can’t generate more searches for a specific keyword. Once you’ve acquired a substantial amount of intent within your market, you’ve basically reached the limit of what searching is capable of.

For B2B and B2C companies, the cost of acquiring customers has gone up by more than 60% in the past five years (ProfitWell). This increase demonstrates what happens when too many companies vie for the same scarce ad space. Clicks become more expensive, and the quality deteriorates. The logic of the cost that made web-search appealing starts to deteriorate as well.

Successful companies notice this trend as it starts to develop. Instead of relying on the web search to get all potential customers into their sales funnel, they see it as the end of the funnel and focus on different tools for the top of the sales funnel.

Formats That Cut Through Where Display Fails

Banner blindness is a real thing. There are various reports on users’ tendencies to ignore rectangular boxes in typical locations on a webpage. So, while your impressions may increase, actual views don’t necessarily follow. This poses a cost efficiency problem for businesses that depend on standard display as the dominant non-search tool.

One particular medium that clears this hurdle is push advertising. As the name suggests, advertising push notification ads appear directly on the user’s interface, the same location on their device where they receive app updates and messages. This space is infinitely more visible, and the engagement rates for users clearly show this. For brands looking to build more reach without the need to compete with banner inventory for areas where users have essentially conditioned themselves to ignore ads, this format provides an altogether different user experience.

The click-through rates are not necessarily higher because the audience is more attentive, but their attention has clearly been caught in a way that a sidebar ad could never achieve.

Building Awareness Before the Search Query Exists

The users who will become your customers in six months don’t know they need you yet. They haven’t typed the query. They’re not in the market. But they can still be reached through display networks, social formats, contextual placements, and high-visibility channels that don’t require purchase intent as an entry point.

This is where direct-to-consumer brands have built their playbook. DTC companies often spend aggressively on awareness formats early, understanding that a user who sees their product multiple times across different environments is far more likely to convert when they do eventually search. The search click at the end of that journey looks cheap. It should, because most of the work was done upstream.

The goal is to introduce the brand before the competition starts. By the time a user gets to a search results page, brand-familiar names have a distinct advantage, even against higher bids.

Attribution Is Where Most Companies Get Stuck

Many companies are not diversifying faster because they are dealing with attribution confusion. For instance, if a user is exposed to a push ad on Tuesday, a social ad on Thursday, and then looks up the brand on Friday and converts, which channel is considered most relevant in the typical attribution model? Search is usually the winner. This means that the awareness-led formats look like they aren’t working, even though they are building intent that other channels are more successful in closing.

This means moving from last-click to a model that gives some credit to all the touchpoints that lead to a conversion. This isn’t hard to do, but the knowledge that some channels are built to begin a pipeline, rather than close efficiency out of the end of it, can be difficult for a leadership team to understand.

Real-time bidding and programmatic buying have made it easier to run and measure these channels efficiently. The infrastructure is in place. The blocker is mostly cultural, as teams measuring last-click don’t know how to estimate the benefit of an assist.

Treating Channel Mix as a Risk Management Decision

There is another important motivation for a diversified approach beyond a growth mindset: resiliency. A company that funnels 80% of ad expenditures through a single channel is overly exposed to the price fluctuations, algorithm changes, and policy updates of that one channel. A sudden spike in Google CPCs or a targeting limitation from Meta can severely impact revenue if alternative traffic sources have not been developed.

Omnichannel distribution not only scales your reach; it scales your resiliency. If one channel becomes pricier or less efficient, the others can compensate while you reoptimize. This is not a nice-to-have for larger businesses; it’s a necessity. If your business is reliant on paid media at any meaningful scale, you need alternative sources of traffic to operate effectively.

Search can fit into this strategy, along with a dozen other channels. It’s a great candidate for an always-on, well-optimized, low-waste component of a broader media mix. It’s just not likely to be your growth engine by itself.

This article features branded content from a third party. Opinions in this article do not reflect the opinions and beliefs of New York Weekly.